The Duluth Leadership Council
Nicki Patnaude works in the LSS Oh No Eighteen (ONE) Program in Duluth. The ONE Program is an independent living skills program for youth aged 16-20. ONE provides services in Duluth, Hibbing and Virginia. She has been a group facilitator for the program for three years, and volunteered for the program for three years before becoming a paid staff member.
As part of my current position, I am a supportive adult leader for the Duluth Youth Leadership Council. The council is comprised of young adults who are either currently in foster care or have aged out of placement. The council has been meeting since October 2007. The council works to educate people about what it is like to be in the foster care system, how difficult it can be to leave care at the age of 18, take action to improve the foster care system, and create support and services for other youth in care. The council will eventually complete a variety of projects ranging from making an information packet for youth entering the system to speaking to social workers, county officials, and state legislatures.
It has been a rough start to this council. While I was personally ecstatic to start this group, and recruited a good group of youth who I believed would work to make a positive change, it has not been without its share of problems. The council started pretty small, comprised of only five members. This council is one of three in the state and I was told I should try to boost my numbers in any way possible. When I told my council this, I sent them home with the assignment of bringing a friend to group. By the end of December, the Duluth YLC was up to eight youth.
January brought about training for all three of the Youth Leadership Councils across the state for a weekend in Bloomington. The training was to help the youth develop a group identity as a state, work out a statewide mission statement, and set the standard for other councils in the future. While at the training, I met with the other leaders to discuss some of the difficulties I was having. The youth in the council are supposed to run bi-monthly groups themselves. My role was designed to help point them in the right direction, if need be, but let them make the decisions on their own. However, because most of the youth have participated in other groups with me, it has been hard for them to see me as only a supporter and not as a group facilitator. The advice I received at the training was to leave the table—remove myself from the situation and see if they fly.
Heading home, I was conflicted about whether or not this would really work. I was nervous, but my co-worker and helper for this group assured me it would, most likely, be the best for them to take ownership of this group. Since the training, the council has met twice. Both meetings have been dreadful. Only five members of the council were able to attend the training and were assigned to update the other members at our first meeting. With me not in the room, the youth had a difficult time getting their points across and relaying what happened at the training. The other meeting was equally as tough. Once I left the room, the youth were off-task and did not accomplish much of anything. After the meeting, many members came up to me on an individual basis to discuss concerns they had. While this is part of my role, I also have to encourage the members to confront each other on the issue, hold each other accountable for their actions and decisions.
Going into our next meeting, I am really conflicted. Should I take some control and help the group get on track or should I let them figure it out for themselves? Should youth be paid for the work they actually do or on the basis of attendance but not participation? What am I so afraid of when it comes to this group—the potential failure of the group or the failure as a supportive adult? It hasn’t been an easy transition from the facilitator to the supportive adult for me either. I would like to let them figure it out and make it work for themselves, but I know that the group is becoming increasingly frustrated with one another, and this frustration may lead members to leave the group. Every situation cannot end with a happy ending, however, is it possible that this group cannot work together right now? Might it be the wrong place and wrong time? Either way, our next meeting will surely be interesting.